Skip to Content

Stargazer Review: The best cast iron pan?

Sharing is caring!

Are you looking for quality cast iron cookware that is practical, safe, and made in the U.S.A.? What if I told you that you could buy quality cookware with a classic design at affordable prices? Allow me to introduce you to a company called Stargazer Cast Iron and its award-winning cookware. Stargazer Cast Iron skillets are smooth, lightweight, and safe, with many impressive features that make them stand out from the rest. This Stargazer Cast Iron review will help you decide which skillet option is best for you and your cooking needs.


✅   After going through all of the Stargazer pans, this is the one that we would buy based on all of its qualities.

About Stargazer Cast Iron Skillet

Stargazer Cast Iron is unique in that it is the only cast-iron brand that utilizes a direct-to-consumer strategy to help make quality cookware pieces more affordable to customers. This means that you can go straight to their website to buy the skillets without dealing with a middleman. This helps keep their prices low, which means more people can access quality cookware at an affordable price.


stargazer cast iron pan review

History of Stargazer Cast Iron Skillets

The company was founded in 2015 by Peter Huntley, a professional kitchenware designer. He wanted to build a company that would manufacture quality cast iron cookware pieces with an attractive design in the United States. The company is also proud that its products are produced sustainably, and the environmental footprint is minimized. (1)


Stargazer Cast Iron Specifics

Stargazer Cast Iron is designed to be smooth. This helps the skillet be non-stick and easier to clean. One of my biggest challenges with cooking with cast iron is how heavy it is. However, Stargazer is different than a traditional cast-iron skillet. With Stargazer Cast Iron, their skillets are lighter weight without sacrificing cast iron’s heat retention.

I hate grabbing a handle while cooking and realizing too little too late just how hot the handle is. Stargazer Cast Iron cookware has a comfortable grip, stay cool handle, which is a beneficial safety feature. The cookware is non-toxic and made from all-natural materials.


Stargazer Cast Iron Review

Overall Features of Stargazer Products:

  • Smooth interior
  • Nonstick qualities
  • Optimized weight
  • The handle is designed to stay cooler for a longer amount of time
  • Rim is flared and drip-free



Stargazer makes high-quality cast iron cookware that will work on a gas or electric stove. One great thing about Stargazer Cast Iron is that you can choose whether you would like your cookware to be bare or seasoned. If you choose the bare finishing, you will need to season it yourself before using it. Bare cookware is dipped in mineral oil to protect it while it is being shipped. Once you receive it, you should wash the oil off and season it however you prefer.

The other option is to buy the cookware from Stargazer already seasoned. If you choose this option, the seasoned skillet will arrive seasoned with two coats of Stargazer’s oil blend, which consists of sunflower, grapeseed, and canola oil. Choosing this option means that your cast iron cookware arrives ready to use straight from the box.



Stargazer Cast Iron prides itself on producing high-quality cookware that is built to last throughout the generations. These are not cheap skillets in terms of material. Domestically sourced iron is used to make the skillet. The made in America designation means you will get a quality, durable product.



To make the skillets, Stargazer Cast Iron uses non-toxic recycled iron that is all-natural. The company seeks out innovative ideas for ways to lessen their carbon footprint, so these products are purchases you can feel good about.


Heating Capacity:

Cast iron cookware is very durable and can handle high temperatures well. You can use your Stargazer Cast Iron skillet on any cooking surface.


Cleaning Instructions:

Cleaning cast iron is not difficult, but it is different from cleaning standard cookware pieces. Using hot water and a rag should be sufficient to clean your Stargazer skillets. Be sure that the skillet is completely dry after cleaning it to avoid rusting.

One easy way to achieve this is to warm it up on the stove after it has been cleaned to ensure all of the water is removed from the skillet. You do not want to use steel wool or an abrasive cleaner as these items will take the pan’s seasoning off.

You also should not use a dishwasher to clean cast iron. The main thing to remember when cleaning cast iron is never to soak it in water!



Stargazer offers two sizes of cast iron skillets – a 10.5-inch skillet and a 12-inch skillet. The 12-inch skillet, the largest size, is my favorite piece, but both are great. These artisan skillets, though affordable, are indistinguishable from high-end skillets.

The smaller skillet has a rim diameter of 10.5 inches, but the cooking surface is 8.1 inches wide. It holds 2.3 quarts and is 2 inches deep.

The larger skillet has a rim diameter of 12 inches, but the cooking surface is 9.4 inches wide. It holds 3.4 quarts and is 2.3 inches deep. This model won the Popular Mechanics’ “Gear of the Year” award in 2021.


Stargazer Cast Iron 10.5 Inch Skillet

stargazer cast iron 10 inch skillet


What’s Included:

  • One medium-sized skillet



  • Great size for cooking for one to two people
  • Non-stick interior
  • Not as heavy as some cast iron cookware – only 5.2 pounds
  • Helper handle stays cooler for a longer amount of time
  • The flared rim is drip-free
  • Infinite warranty
  • American made



  • The handle shape may be uncomfortable for some users
  • Cast iron care can be cumbersome
  • The weight of the skillet may be too heavy for some people’s preferences
  • Sometimes there can be shipping delays.


Overall Stargazer Cast Iron 10-Inch Skillet Review

stargazer cast iron pan review

While the rim diameter of this skillet is 10.5 inches, the diameter of the cooking surface is 8.1 inches. This is a perfect size if you are cooking for one or two people. If you dislike the weight of traditional cast iron pans, you may prefer this lighter skillet. It is also easy to clean this piece. Just place the skillet under warm water, wipe it out, and dry it off. If you want to buy a high-quality cast iron skillet that is reasonably priced, this Stargazer 10-inch skillet is a great option.

Click here to buy this cookware  

Stargazer Cast Iron 12-Inch Skillet

stargazer cast iron 12 inch skillet

What’s Included:

  • One large skillet – great for cooking for a family


  • Smooth surface interior
  • Weighs 6.5 pounds
  • Handle stays cooler longer
  • The flared rim is drip-free
  • Infinite warranty
  • American made


  • Some users find the handle shape to be difficult to grab
  • Cast iron is heavy
  • Cast iron requires specialized care

Overall Stargazer Cast Iron 12-Inch Skillet Review

stargazer 12 cast iron skillet

Do you regularly cook for more than 2 people? If so, upgrading to the 12-inch skillet is a great option. This cast-iron skillet is easy to use and maintain as long as you understand how to care for cast iron properly. Instead of a traditional pour spout, Stargazer Cast Iron skillets feature a flared rim that allows for drip-free pouring from any angle. The aesthetically pleasing design and functionality make this skillet a great option for your home kitchen.


Click here to buy this cookware  


How Does Stargazer Cast Iron Compare to Other Cookware?

Stargazer Cast Iron vs. Lodge

Both companies sell cast iron cookware for cheaper than other high-end lines. However, Stargazer Cast Iron’s seasoning process and hand-polished finish provide superior anti-stick cooking capabilities. Learn more about them in our Lodge cast iron review.

Stargazer Cast Iron vs. Field

At this time, Stargazer Cast Iron only offers two products – the two sizes of skillets. Field offers 5 sizes of skillets.

Stargazer Cast Iron vs. Smithey

Smithey offers multiple sizes of cast iron skillets, griddles, and dutch ovens if you want a variety of cookware options.

Click here to buy this cookware  


Stargazer Cast Iron ​FAQ

What is the difference between Stargazer Cast Iron 10.5-Inch Skillet and Stargazer Cast Iron 12-Inch Skillet?

The construction and features of the two skillets are the same. You have to decide which size is better for your cooking needs. The 10.5-inch skillet is best for 1 – 2 people. If you regularly cook for more than two people, consider purchasing the larger-sized skillet.

Where is Stargazer Cast Iron made?

Stargazer Cast Iron is proudly made in three U.S. states. Casting is done in Wisconsin. Then machining occurs in Ohio. Finally, the products make their way to Pennsylvania for inspection and the finishing process. Seasoning and product fulfillment are also done in Pennsylvania.

What is Stargazer Cast Iron warranty?

Stargazer Cast Iron is designed to last for generations. The company offers to repair or replace cookware pieces that are defective or fail when used properly. This warranty offer does not expire.

Is Stargazer Cast Iron dishwasher safe?

No. Cast iron should not be placed in the dishwasher.

Is Stargazer Cast Iron oven-safe?

Yes. Stargazer Cast Iron can be used in the oven. Just be careful when removing it from the oven as it will be very hot.

Is Stargazer cast iron safe?

Yes. The oil blend used to season the skillets is 100% certified non-GMO and does not contain any animal products. If you are concerned about allergies, the seasoning is also peanut, soy, and gluten-free.

Where can I buy a Stargazer Cast Iron Skillet?

To buy Stargazer Cast Iron skillets, go to their website and click shop.

What is seasoning?

Seasoning involves baking a layer of fat or oil onto the pan. This is done to protect the plan and helps with sticking. Don’t worry – the seasoning of the cookware does not impact the taste of your food.

What does it mean to season a pan?

To season a pan means to apply oil or fat to the cast iron to form a hard shell to protect your cast iron. This also helps with the non-stick nature of the pans. Seasoning is a natural and renewable coating. To renew the seasoning, preheat your skillet for 5-10 minutes using a low heat source. Then wipe a little cooking oil onto the skillet’s cooking surface and heat it for another 5-10 minutes. The oil will look dry when it is done.

Click here to buy this cookware  

Can you use Cast Iron on an Induction Cooktop?

Yes, in certain cases you can use cast iron on induction cooktops but before you do you need to check a few things, and possibly alter your pan. For more read our post: Can Cast Iron be Used on Induction Cooktops?

Why Should You Buy Stargazer Cast Iron?

If you are looking to add a quality cast iron skillet to your home kitchen, consider buying from Stargazer. The company is proud of its Made in America status and is committed to making products entirely in the United States.

Stargazer Cast Iron is also passionate about sustainability. They offer non-toxic, all-natural cookware that is built to last. Because such quality cookware can last for generations, it creates less waste than cheaper cookware pieces that have to be replaced regularly.

In addition to getting a quality piece of cookware, when you buy from Stargazer Cast Iron, you are also supporting important social causes because a portion of proceeds are donated to various causes.


Is Stargazer Cast Iron worth it?

Stargazer Cast Iron is worth checking out if you want to buy a quality cast iron skillet built to last for generations. It is important to keep in mind that cast iron requires special care; however, this line of skillets offers some very compelling features, such as the flared rim and smooth cooking surface. The indefinite warranty is also a great benefit to purchasing from Stargazer Cast Iron.


Final Thoughts About Stargazer Cast Iron

This company offers a quality product that is made entirely in the U.S.A. They care about sustainability and give back a portion of the proceeds to various causes. If you want to purchase cast iron and want to feel good about supporting local jobs, check out Stargazer Cast Iron.

Click here to buy this cookware  


Looking for more of the best cookware brands?
Or if you are searching for a brand here are our cookware brand reviews


Source: 1 –

This post may contain affiliate links which go towards keeping this site running. Please see our Disclaimer and Privacy Policy for more. We are a member in the Amazon Affiliate Program. Thank you for your support!